01 · Look a little closer
Ask what “natural” means.
Citrine is the yellow-to-orange variety of quartz. Amethyst is purple quartz, and heating some amethyst changes its colour to shades sold as citrine. GIA explains that naturally coloured citrine is uncommon and that much commercial citrine owes its colour to heat treatment.
A mined quartz crystal can therefore have a human-altered colour. That is a different question from whether an object is glass or another imitation. If a listing simply says “natural”, ask whether that describes the material’s formation or also claims an untreated colour.
02 · Look a little closer
Use the colour clues to ask better questions.
In the Short, the pale base and strongly orange tips are described as clues associated with heated amethyst. Look at where the colour sits: at the points, through the body, or in uneven patches. Our separate collection photograph gives you another view to describe.
Those observations are not a conclusive home test. Lighting, camera settings and the specimen itself affect what you see. Keep “orange tips and pale base” in your observations, and “possibly heat-treated” in your interpretation. A photograph cannot establish the full treatment history of this piece.
03 · Look a little closer
Before buying, get the description in writing.
Ask the seller: Is heat treatment known or suspected? What evidence supports any claim of untreated colour? Is the locality documented or simply supplied with the specimen? Keep their answers with the receipt and your own photographs. An honest “unknown” is useful information.
A treated specimen can still be an enjoyable part of a collection. Choose it for the qualities you can see and the description the seller can support. If untreated colour is essential to a costly purchase, ask a qualified gemologist which assessment is appropriate before relying on that claim; do not assume every report answers every treatment question.
Pause. Replay. Describe.
Try this while watching
- Watch once and note the difference between the base and the crystal tips.
- Make two short lists: What I can see, and What I would need evidence to know.
- Write one seller question using the words “untreated colour” rather than only asking whether the stone is real.
Sources and further reading
Written for Rock & Crystal Secrets. Video narration and mineral references checked 17 October 2026. This is an original reading companion, not a transcript or a laboratory identification.




