01 · Observe
Describe it before naming it.
Place the stone on a plain background in ordinary light. Write down its main colour, then look for bands, flecks or cloudy areas. Turn it gently and note what changes. Two stones can share a colour, so keep gathering clues.
Next describe its lustre: does the surface look glassy, metallic, silky or dull? Look at existing faces and edges. A polished point was shaped by a person; its outline alone cannot tell you how the mineral grew.
Can you see clearly through it, only light through it, or neither? These observations are called transparent, translucent and opaque. Different parts of one specimen can give different answers.
Your first-look checklist
Collect clues you can describe.
- Colour and pattern: one colour or several? Bands, spots or cloudy areas?
- Surface shine: glassy, silky, metallic or dull? Use lustre to describe it.
- Shape: natural faces, a rough fragment or a polished object? Record “uncertain” if you cannot tell.
- Light through the stone: clear view, light only, or no light through the area you checked?
- Movement: does a band or flash shift as the stone turns in ordinary light?
- Context: size, supplied label and where it came from. Mark seller claims separately.
Write the answers on the observation sheet. Missing a clue is fine; do not turn a guess into a measurement.
02 · Look beyond colour
Purple is a clue, not a name.
Different minerals can share a colour, and one mineral can occur in several colours. A purple stone might suggest amethyst or purple fluorite, among other possibilities. Colour can help you choose what to compare, but it cannot finish the identification.
In our amethyst and fluorite comparison, look at natural growth faces and existing break surfaces as well as shade. Fluorite can form cubes or octahedra, but not every specimen shows these shapes clearly. A carved tower’s outline is a maker’s choice.
Compare amethyst and purple fluorite →03 · Compare
Make a shortlist, then look for differences.
Choose two plausible guides and compare the details one at a time. A match in colour is a starting point, not a verdict.
- Clear Quartz and Calcite: compare the published shape and cleavage clues. Both can look clear.
- Pyrite and Tiger’s Eye: compare metallic reflections with a moving silky band.
- Obsidian and Hematite: compare a glassy surface with metallic or earthy appearances.
Use the encyclopedia filters to make a shortlist, then read the full guides. A filter result is a browsing suggestion, not an identification. For each possible match, note one supporting clue, one mismatch and one unknown. Do not ignore a mismatch just because the colour looks right.
Our collection photos show individual examples. A reference photo also shows only one specimen, not every possible appearance of that material.
Check the story too
Keep a label separate from an observation.
Save the seller’s name, label and any treatment disclosure with your notes. Our beginner buying guide has questions to ask before purchasing. “The label says Citrine” and “I can see orange-yellow crystal tips” are different kinds of evidence. A photo cannot settle every treatment or origin question.
Trade names can describe mixtures or commercial products. Read the notes on Caribbean Calcite for an example. Traditional associations are labelled separately from mineral facts throughout our encyclopedia.
04 · Keep the answer provisional
A useful first entry in your notebook
Observed: purple colour, glassy shine, several pointed crystals, some cloudy areas.
Possible match: Amethyst; compare purple fluorite too. Still uncertain: whether the faces are natural, the identity, treatment history and origin.
Next step: photograph another side and compare the shape notes. If the piece is polished or the useful surfaces are hidden, leave the answer open.
A careful “possibly” is more useful than a confident guess. For a valuable stone or a firm identification, ask a qualified gemmologist or mineral specialist what examination is appropriate.
Learn the properties without damaging your stone.
Mohs hardness describes resistance to scratching, not resistance to breaking. Use the hardness values in our guides as reference information for now. Skip scratch, acid and streak tests on your display pieces; do not taste unknown minerals or create dust.
Begin with observation. If further testing is needed, let someone with the right equipment and specimen knowledge guide it.
How to care for your specimen →05 · Take the next question to a specialist
When the clues do not settle it.
If the stone is valuable, the label is disputed, or treatment and origin affect a buying decision, ask a qualified gemmologist or mineral specialist what examination is needed. A photograph, an app suggestion or a similar-looking example can help frame a question; none is a laboratory report.
Prepare clear, unfiltered photos of several sides on a plain background, include a ruler for scale, and copy the original label exactly. Explain which features you observed and which details came from the seller. Avoid destructive tests while waiting for advice.
A useful result can be “still unknown”. Keep the record so better evidence can be added later.
Sources and further reading
- British Geological Survey: mineral properties (PDF; opens in a new tab)
- Minerals Education Coalition: fluorite and its forms (opens in a new tab)
- Earthlearningidea: observing mineral properties (PDF)
- GIA: hardness, toughness and gem durability
Expanded and references checked 20 October 2026. This page helps you organise observations; it does not identify an unknown stone for you.


